| Name | Team | TOTAL |
| Davey van ‘t Schip | Pascoe Vale | 10 |
| Damian Iaconis | Kingston City | 7 |
| Matthew Thurtell | Bentleigh Greens | 6 |
| Kenny Athiu | Heidelberg United | 6 |
| Jonatan Germano | Avondale FC | 5 |
| Sean Ellis | Heidelberg United | 5 |
| Liam Boland | Hume City | 5 |
| Elvis Kamsoba | Melbourne Knights | 5 |
| Oleksiy Khrapko | Port Melbourne | 5 |
| Milos Lujic | South Melbourne | 5 |
| Lambros Honos | Bentleigh Greens | 4 |
| Alex Caniglia | Green Gully | 4 |
| Velibor Mitrovic | Kingston City | 4 |
| Tom Cahill | Melbourne Knights | 4 |
| Craig Carley | Avondale FC | 3 |
| Ben Litfin | Bentleigh Greens | 3 |
| Jay Davies | Green Gully | 3 |
| Nick Krousoratis | Green Gully | 3 |
| Wade Dekker | Green Gully | 3 |
| Jason Hicks | Melbourne Knights | 3 |
| Dean Piemonte | Oakleigh Cannons | 3 |
| Andreas Govas | Port Melbourne | 3 |
| Francesco Stella | Port Melbourne | 3 |
| Matthew Millar | South Melbourne | 3 |
| Kamal Ibrahim | Avondale FC | 2 |
| Andy Brennan | Bentleigh Greens | 2 |
| Trent Clulow | Bentleigh Greens | 2 |
| Jordan Templin | Bulleen Lions | 2 |
| Oliver White | Bulleen Lions | 2 |
| Atilla Ofli | Hume City | 2 |
| James McGarry | Hume City | 2 |
| Sean McIlroy | Kingston City | 2 |
| Andrew Doig | North Geelong Warriors | 2 |
| Luca Santilli | Pascoe Vale | 2 |
| Leigh Minopoulos | South Melbourne | 2 |
| Matthew Cundari | St Albans Saints | 2 |
| James Cumming | Avondale FC | 1 |
| Kaine Sheppard | Avondale FC | 1 |
| Keanu Moore | Bentleigh Greens | 1 |
| Andrew Mullett | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| Brad Clarke | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| Christian McKenna | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| Davide Cardamone | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| Dylan Bresolin | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| Luke Gallo | Bulleen Lions | 1 |
| George Lambadaridis | Green Gully | 1 |
| Jonathan Bounas | Green Gully | 1 |
| Luke Walker | Green Gully | 1 |
| Sami Nour | Green Gully | 1 |
| Stephen Hatzikostas | Green Gully | 1 |
| Adrian Zahra | Heidelberg United | 1 |
| Luke Byles | Heidelberg United | 1 |
| Reuben Way | Heidelberg United | 1 |
| Daniel Clark | Hume City | 1 |
| Nick Hegarty | Hume City | 1 |
| Wayne Wallace | Hume City | 1 |
| Erhan Yalaz | Kingston City | 1 |
| Mouad Zwed | Kingston City | 1 |
| Slaven Vranesevic | Kingston City | 1 |
| Caleb Mikulic | Melbourne Knights | 1 |
| Danny Dixon | Melbourne Knights | 1 |
| Ivan Grgic | North Geelong Warriors | 1 |
| Josh Pugh | North Geelong Warriors | 1 |
| Juso Julardzija | North Geelong Warriors | 1 |
| Kene Eze | North Geelong Warriors | 1 |
| Matthew Thorne | North Geelong Warriors | 1 |
| Dusan Bosnjak | Oakleigh Cannons | 1 |
| Giuseppe Marafioti | Oakleigh Cannons | 1 |
| Ioannis Georgopoulos | Oakleigh Cannons | 1 |
| Kostantinos Stratomitros | Oakleigh Cannons | 1 |
| Steve Pantelidis | Oakleigh Cannons | 1 |
| Joseph Youssef | Pascoe Vale | 1 |
| Michael Ferrante | Pascoe Vale | 1 |
| Quaynor Mustapha | Pascoe Vale | 1 |
| Bonel Obradovic | Port Melbourne | 1 |
| Calvin Mbarga | Port Melbourne | 1 |
| Chris Cristaldo | Port Melbourne | 1 |
| Marcus Schroen | South Melbourne | 1 |
| Nick Epifano | South Melbourne | 1 |
| Luis Covarrubias | St Albans Saints | 1 |
Updated: 18th April 2017